The court reverses the final judgment in this quiatimet and ejectment action that divested defendant State of New Jersey of its title to seven parcels of land in the Preservation Area of the Pinelands National Reserve, consisting of over 250 acres, and granted title to those properties to an adjoining landowner, plaintiff Phoenix Pinelands Corporation, operator of a grandfathered sand and gravel mine. The court declares Phoenix's surreptitious, two-decade-long quest to undermine and cloud the State's title to the properties and establish its own competing chains of title — by plotting and resurveying the titles from the original grants from the Council of Proprietors of West Jersey, searching those titles forward, purchasing the fractional interests of the descendants of long-dead record title holders, convincing the tax assessor of Little Egg Harbor to make Phoenix's principal, David Denise, the assessed owner of the State's properties, consolidating the State's lands with Phoenix's sand mine, and having the State's parcels wiped off the tax map — the nefarious acts of a title raider, which should have barred it from any relief in a court of equity.
Having declared Phoenix's attempted annexation of the State's lands as violative of public policy, the court imposes a constructive trust on the "title" Phoenix acquired to one of the State's seven parcels, finding the State equitably entitled to the parcel upon payment to Phoenix of the sum it paid to acquire it, plus simple interest, and further finds Phoenix failed to establish title to any of the State's remaining six parcels under theories of quia timet or ejectment.
Accordingly, the court remands for entry of judgment in recordable form, following the State's tender of payment as described above, declaring Denise and Phoenix have no interest in these State lands and adjudging the State the owner of each parcel in fee simple.