Tax Court: Mitchell Medoff v. Dir., Div. of Tax’n;. Docket No. 009867-2018, opinion by Cimino, J.T.C., decided March 1, 2019. For plaintiff - David S. Neufel and Jeremy S. Cole (Flaster Greenberg, attorneys); for defendant – Ramanjit K. Chawla (Gurbir S. Grewal, Attorney General of New Jersey, attorney).
In 2009, the Legislature amended the law to tax lottery winnings. Previously, such winnings were free from income tax. Plaintiff paid taxes from 2009 through 2012 on installments from a 1993 prize. After the Tax Court’s decisions in 2016 holding the 2009 law invalid as it applied to prizes won prior to its enactment, plaintiff sought a refund. The refund was sought outside the three year statute of limitations imposed on Gross Income Tax refunds.
Even if a tax provision is found to be invalid, a refund can only be allowed in accordance with statute. Plaintiff could have filed a timely request for refund as did the lottery winners in the 2016 decisions invalidating the retroactive application of the 2009 law. There is not any equitable basis such as square corners or manifest injustice to override the statute of limitations in this case.