Skip to main content
.
Search
Search
Translate this page
Portal Log In
MENU
CLOSE
Search
Search
Self-Represented
Represent Yourself In Court
Appeals
Guide to Completing Appeals Forms
Municipal Court Appeals
Supreme Court Appeals
Child Abuse, Kinship, and Adoption
Child Support and Custody
Filing a Case
Emergent Hearings
Responding to a Complaint
Change a Court Order
Filing Fees and Fee Waivers
Custody and Visitation
Consent Conference
Child Support
Glossary
Civil eCourts Access
Collecting Money in a Civil Judgment
Court Records
Criminal Justice Programs
Divorce
Contested and Uncontested Divorces
Responding to a Divorce Complaint
Modifying a Divorce Order
Appealing a contested divorce case
Glossary
Domestic Violence
Domestic Violence FAQs
Expunging Your Court Record
Fee Waiver
Family Post-Judgment Motions
How to File
Glossary
Firearm Removal
Forms Catalog
Forms Help
Foreclosure
Guardianship
Juvenile Delinquency
Landlord/Tenant
Lawsuits $5,000 or less (Small Claims)
Lawsuits $20,000 or less (Special Civil)
Lawsuits over $20,000 (Civil)
Legal Reference Materials
Notice on AI
Municipal Court
Name Change
Name Change for Adults
Name Change for Minors Under Age 18
Probation Client Portal
Rules and References
Submit Court Documents Online (JEDS)
Submit Evidence Files Online
Tax Court
County Boards of Taxation Links
Docketed Cases
Attorneys
Administrative Directives
Artificial Intelligence - Use in the Courts
Attorney Ethics and Discipline
Attorney Resources
Approved Trust Account Banks
Attorney Regulatory Board
Certificates and Forms
File a Fee Dispute
District Ethics and Fee Committees
Disciplinary Review Board
Random Audit Program
File an Ethics Grievance
Find a Discipline Case
Find an Attorney Regulatory Case
Attorney Registration and Payment
Frequently Asked Questions
Attorney Regulation and Compliance
Board on Attorney Certification
Apply for Certification
Apply for Recertification
Rules and Regulations
Marketing Resources
Calendars & Schedules
Civil Motion Calendar
Continuing Legal Education
Forms and Resources
New Attorneys
Provider Info
Frequently Asked Questions
Court Opinions
Supreme Court Opinions
Expected Opinions
Published Appellate Court Opinions
Unpublished Appellate Court Opinions
Published Tax Court Opinions
Unpublished Tax Court Opinions
Published Trial Court Opinions
Unpublished Trial Court Opinions
Business Opinions
Complex Business Litigation Program
Business Disputes
Business Governance
Contract Disputes
Employment Disputes
Insurance Coverage
Intellectual Property and Technology
Miscellaneous Actions
See All Opinions Summaries
Opinion Summaries Archive
eCourts and eFiling
eCDR
eCourts Appellate
eCourts Civil
eCourts Criminal
eCourts Tax
eCourts
eCourts FAQs
eCourts Training/Guides
Judicial Education and Performance
Judicial Ethics and Conduct
Find an ACJC Case
Judiciary Account Charge System (JACS)
Jury Reform and Voir Dire Pilot
Model Civil Jury Charges System
Model Criminal Jury Charges
Criminal Sample Verdict Sheets
Multicounty Litigation
Notices to the Bar
Pro Bono
Statewide Pro Bono Coordinator List
Remote Court Instructions
Rules of Court
Rules of Evidence
Article I
Article II
Article III
Article IV
Article V
Article VI
Article VII
Article VIII
Article IX
Article X
Article XI
Supreme Court Committee Reports
NJMCdirect
Jurors
Complete Your Questionnaire
Contact Jury Manager
Excusal Requests
FAQs
General Jury Information
New Jersey State Grand Jury
Protect Yourself Against Jury Duty Scams
Reporting Information
Atlantic
Bergen
Burlington
Camden
Cape May
Cumberland
Essex
Gloucester
Hudson
Hunterdon
Mercer
Middlesex
Monmouth
Morris
Ocean
Passaic
Salem
Somerset
Sussex
Union
Warren
State Grand Jury
Rescheduling Requests
Videoconference Instructions
Courts
Supreme Court
About the Supreme Court
Argument Schedule
Attorney Administration
Judicial Conference on Jury Selection
Supreme Court Appeals
Supreme Court Committees
Supreme Court Webcast
Recent Arguments
Appellate Division of Superior Court
Appellate Livestreams
Argument Schedule
Briefs from Argued Cases
Estimated Costs for Transcripts
Pretrial Detention
Request a Transcript
Transcript Processing Offices
Superior Court Clerk's Office
Copies of Court Records
Data Reports for Sale
Electronic Access to Court Records
Foreclosure
Pre-foreclosure
Tax Court
Municipal Court
Cassidy DWI Cases
Dismissal of Old Cases
Marijuana Expungements
Millville Municipal Court Report
Municipal Court Case Law
Recently Enacted Laws
Municipal Court Jobs
Civil Practice
Adult Guardianship
Affordable Housing
Atlantic County
Bergen County
Burlington County
Camden County
Cape May County
Cumberland County
Essex County
Gloucester County
Hudson County
Hunterdon County
Mercer County
Middlesex County
Monmouth County
Morris County
Ocean County
Passaic County
Salem County
Somerset County
Sussex County
Union County
Warren County
Arbitration
Arbitration Administrators and CDR Point Persons
Civil Mediation
Complementary Dispute Resolution
Complex Business Litigation
Criminal Practice
Family Practice
Economic Mediation in Family Law Cases
Parenting Coordinator Program
Family Division Offices
Probation for Adults
Fines, Restitution and Community Service
JOBS Program
Mental Health Supervision
Intensive Supervision Program (ISP)
Pretrial Intervention Supervision
Recovery Court Program
Glossary
Probation Child Support Enforcement
Probation for Juveniles
Atlantic/Cape May Superior Courts
Atlantic/Cape May Court Offices/Divisions
Bergen Superior Court
Bergen Court Offices/Divisions
Burlington Superior Court
Burlington Court Offices/Divisions
Camden Superior Court
Camden Court Offices/Divisions
Cumberland/Gloucester/Salem Superior Courts
Cumberland/Gloucester/Salem Court Offices/Divisions
Essex Superior Court
Essex Court Offices/Divisions
Hudson Superior Court
Hudson Court Offices/Divisions
Mercer Superior Court
Mercer Court Offices/Divisions
Middlesex Superior Court
Middlesex Court Offices/Divisions
Monmouth Superior Court
Monmouth Court Offices/Divisions
Morris/Sussex Superior Courts
Morris/Sussex Court Offices/Divisions
Ocean Superior Court
Ocean Court Offices/Divisions
Passaic Superior Court
Passaic Court Offices/Divisions
Somerset/Hunterdon/Warren Superior Courts
Somerset/Hunterdon/Warren Court Offices/Divisions
Union Superior Court
Union Court Offices/Divisions
Public
ADA Accommodation
Court Closings-Municipal Courts
Court Closings-State Courts
Court Livestreams
Criminal Justice Reform
Directories
Court Services
AOC Contact Directory
Employee (Title I) ADA Coordinators
TASC Contact List
Court User (Title II) ADA Coordinators
Civil Division Offices Directory
Clerks / Legal Offices
Superior Court Special Civil Part
Criminal Division
EEO / AA
County Surrogates
Superior Court Family Division
Municipal Court
Ombudsman
Judge Directories
Judges Contact Directory
Recovery Court Judges and Coordinators Contact List
AJs and TCAs
Civil Presiding Judges
Complex Business Litigation Judges
General Equity Presiding Judges
Criminal Presiding Judges
Designated Environmental Litigation Judges
Designated Mt. Laurel Judges
Designated OPRA Judges
Family Presiding Judges
Judges' Biographies
Judges' Chambers
Municipal Presiding Judges
Probate Part Judges
Special Civil Part Supervising Judges
Tax Court Judges Directory
Division Managers
Civil Division Manager Conference Contact List
Criminal Division Manager Conference Contact List
Family Division Manager Conference Contact List
Finance Division Manager Conference Contact List
Human Resources Division Manager Conference Contact List
Municipal Division Manager Conference Contact List
Operations Division Managers Contact List
Probation Division Manager Contact List
Elder Justice
Fair Treatment in Our Courts
Access and Fairness Committee
Diversity, Inclusion, & Community Engagement
Equal Justice Action Plans
Find a Case
Civil and Foreclosure Public Access
Judgment Lien Public Access
Tax Case Public Access
Get Help
Interpreting Services
Jobs and Clerkships
Become a Law Clerk
Benefits
ADA Accommodations
EEO/AA
Fair Treatment Contact Information by Vicinage
Employee Code of Conduct
Other Opportunities
Language Services
Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection
Mental Health Resources
News and Media
Top News
Notable Cases
NJ Judiciary/Dept of Justice Memorandum of Agreement
Ombudsman Office
Public Bidding Opportunities
Publications and Reports
Statistics
Student Resources
Tell Us How We're Doing
Upcoming Events
Virtual Museum
Volunteer Services
Atlantic
Bergen
Burlington
Camden
Cape May
Cumberland
Essex
Gloucester
Hudson
Hunterdon
Mercer
Middlesex
Monmouth
Morris
Ocean
Passaic
Salem
Somerset
Sussex
Union
Warren
A-2879-23
Home
A-2879-23
A-2879-23
KAREN SIBALICH, ET AL. VS. NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, ET AL.
Briefs
A-2879-23 Briefs
A-2879-23 briefs
Argued:
May 6, 2026