On leave granted, the court holds that the tax filings of corporations and other businesses receive the same presumption of confidentiality as individual tax records. Hence, the heightened requirements for disclosure specified in Ullmann v. Hartford Fire Ins. Co., 87 N.J. Super. 409 (App. Div. 1965), apply to such business tax filings as well.
As Ullmann instructs, a civil litigant can only obtain an opposing party's tax filings through discovery by demonstrating to the court: (1) the filings are relevant to the case; (2) there is a "compelling need for the documents because the information likely to be contained within them is "not otherwise readily obtainable" from other sources; and (3) disclosure would serve a "substantial purpose." Id. at 415-16.